Summary
The caregiver shortage can’t be solved by hiring more people alone. Good caregiver recruitment starts with identifying the right candidates, clearly explaining pay, shifts, and location, simplifying the application process, checking that candidates are a good fit, and acting quickly. While effective recruitment strategies can help agencies build a healthier applicant pool, overcoming the home care staffing shortage also requires thinking about what happens after a caregiver accepts the position—namely, onboarding, preparation, engagement, and ongoing development.
Demand for home-based care is growing, but finding enough caregivers to meet it remains a major challenge. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, employment of home health and personal care aides is projected to grow 18% from 2025 to 2035, with about 760,500 job openings each year.
For home care agencies, this growing workforce need makes caregiver recruitment and retention increasingly important. This blog explores the role of in-home caregivers, what is contributing to the caregiver shortage in the United States, and practical ways agencies can strengthen their workforce.
In-home caregivers provide day-by-day or week-by-week care to people who need ongoing help with certain activities because of short-term or long-term limitations caused by age, illness, injury, or disability. The care they provide helps clients stay in the comfort and security of their own homes for as long as possible. Moreover, in-home caregivers help clients live more satisfying, independent lives and fully participate in their communities.
There are many different types of caregivers, like:
The caregiver shortage is a serious problem for many senior living facilities and home care providers nationwide. As an employer, you can take several measures to address this issue early.
To tackle the caregiver shortage, consider the following:
The biggest constraint in caregiver recruiting is that job boards show your role only to people actively searching. In any given week in your service area, that’s a small and heavily contested group — and every agency within driving distance is bidding on the same people.
The caregiver you actually want is usually already employed. They may be working days at a facility twenty minutes away or with another agency whose schedule no longer works. They may consider moving for a shorter commute, better pay, or a shift that fits their schedule. But they may never see your job posting because they aren’t actively searching job boards.
That’s the entire case for paid social in this category: it doesn’t require search intent. This is also why the channel performs best in thin markets. Where a job board produces nothing because nobody in that county searched this week, cost per applicant isn’t low — it’s undefined. A more expensive applicant who exists beats a cheaper one who doesn’t.
Before looking at anything else, caregivers consider three factors: pay, shift start date, and distance. Only after reviewing these three points do they read the other aspects of the job advertisement, such as the mission, the values, the benefits, and the culture.
Most agency job ads bury all three. They open with a paragraph about compassionate care and a commitment to dignity, then list requirements, then mention a pay range near the bottom, if at all.
Put them in the first two lines. Specifically:
There’s a retention argument here too. Overstating any of the three buys you a hire and a 60-day departure — and nearly four in five caregivers who leave do so within their first 100 days. The honest ad produces fewer applicants and better ones.
Strengthen your hiring approach with Learn2Care’s practical strategies to attract and recruit the right caregivers.
This is the highest-leverage change most agencies can make, and it costs nothing.
Across healthcare campaigns, application completion varies enormously by how long the form is:
| Role | Application completion rate | Cost per applicant |
| Caregiver/ home health aide | 31.3% | $3.47 |
| LPN/ LVN | 18.4% | $12.14 |
| CNA/ nurse aide | 17.4% | $6.82 |
| RN/ registered nurse | 12.4% | $15.93 |
Caregiver applications convert at nearly three times the rate of caregiver RN applications. Some of that is genuine candidate behavior — but a large share is form length. Clinical applications ask for license numbers, certification dates, references, and resume uploads at the front of the process, from someone tapping an ad on a phone during a break.
Ask only questions that disqualify a candidate. For most caregiver positions, this involves four questions: whether they are available for the required shifts, whether they have reliable transport, whether they are willing to travel the stated distance, and whether they have the required experience. All the other things—such as references, certifications, and background forms should be dealt with after you have spoken to them.
A shorter application reduces hiring friction. The next step is creating an onboarding process that gets caregivers ready without unnecessary repetition.
The knockout questions in your application aren’t only a filter for quality. They’re your cheapest retention tool.
Nearly four in five caregiver departures happen within the first 100 days, and the common causes are unglamorous: they accepted days and got weekends, the client is thirty-five minutes each way with unpaid travel, they were told 30 hours and got 18. Those aren’t retention failures. They’re hiring failures that surface later — and each one is knowable before an offer is made.
Asking about shift availability and travel radius at the point of application directly addresses the top two causes of early exit.
The difference is genuine. The more questions you include, the more people you filter out before they submit, which increases cost per applicant while reducing the screening your scheduler has to do. There is no single correct setting:
Most agencies have never made this an explicit decision. It’s a dial, and you’re holding it one way or the other.
Hiring for fit is only the beginning. A structured first 90 days can help new caregivers integrate, engage, and stay.
Caregivers apply to several agencies in one sitting, usually on a phone, during a break. The agency that responds within minutes is talking to someone still thinking about working. The agency that calls back in two days is calling someone who already started somewhere else.
This matters more in home care than in almost any other frontline sector, because the roles are close substitutes. If three agencies in your market pay within a dollar of each other, response speed is the differentiator — not your benefits page or your Glassdoor rating.
The practical solution is to send an automated SMS when the form is submitted. It doesn’t replace an actual conversation; it keeps their attention until you can engage them.
A useful diagnostic: Measure your median time from application to first human contact, in minutes. Most agencies that measure it for the first time are surprised.
Fast follow-up helps secure candidates. Effective onboarding and training help prepare them for what comes next.
This one sounds obvious and gets ignored.
An agency choosing from three applicants takes who it can get. An agency choosing from thirty hires for fit — the right shift, the right radius, the right temperament for a particular client. The second agency has better retention, and it isn’t because they’re better at retention.
According to Boostpoint.com, a caregiver applicant costs $3.47; generating thirty applicants instead of three costs roughly $100. The cost of one caregiver departure is estimated at $2,600 to $5,000.
For most agencies, ad budget has never been the binding constraint. It’s whether enough qualified people ever see the role.
A reliable caregiver pipeline gives your agency the capacity to grow without compromising workforce readiness.
Research indicates that the population aged 65 and over is expected to double between 2000 and 2030, showing how urgently more caregivers are needed. Meanwhile, the national caregiver shortfall is estimated at 151,000 by 2030 and 355,000 by 2040. Several factors contribute to the shortage of non-medical and home health nursing services, which we will discuss in more detail below.
Caregiving is generally regarded as a low-status job, making it hard to attract and retain skilled professionals. This image is strengthened by the fact that the workforce in this field is mainly made up of women. Moreover, the way in which seniors and people with disabilities are marginalized and excluded hurts society’s perception of non-medical and home healthcare workers.
Entry requirements and compensation for caregiving roles often do not reflect the work’s responsibilities and demands. Caregivers may provide personal care, support daily activities, observe changes in a person’s condition, follow care plans, and respond appropriately to safety concerns—all while managing physically and emotionally demanding situations.
Low wages, limited hours, and inconsistent schedules can make it hard to attract and retain caregivers, especially when workers can find better-paying or more predictable work in other industries.
Caregiving can be physically and emotionally demanding. Caregivers may manage changing schedules, travel between clients, physically demanding tasks, emotional stress, and varying workloads. Limited or inconsistent hours can add further challenges, particularly when compensation does not reflect the demands of the role.
These pressures can contribute to burnout and turnover, making it harder for home care agencies to build and maintain a stable caregiver workforce.
Other healthcare jobs often have a clearly defined path for career advancement and new opportunities. But caregiving is not always presented that way. Yet the skills caregivers develop can be valuable for careers both within and outside the home care industry. The caregiving field has significant growth potential, but these opportunities are not always clearly defined or promoted.
Being honest about the limits of this advice:
Recruiting caregivers is only the first step. Once a caregiver accepts the job, the focus shifts to helping them understand their role, build confidence, develop the right skills, and stay engaged over time. A structured training experience can help agencies turn new hires into more prepared members of the care team.
New caregivers need more than paperwork and policy lists. Learn2Care helps agencies create a consistent onboarding experience with state-aligned and agency-specific training, so caregivers can learn applicable requirements, essential care practices, and agency expectations from the beginning. See how agencies can reduce redundant training and improve caregiver onboarding.
With 65+ hours of professional caregiver training, agencies can support learning across essential care skills, safety, communication, infection prevention, condition-specific care, and other topics caregivers may encounter in their work. For a closer look at what effective training can include, explore this direct care worker training guide.
Training should not end once orientation is complete. Ongoing learning gives caregivers opportunities to refresh essential skills, expand their knowledge, and prepare for changing responsibilities and care needs. A strong first few months can also play an important role in integration and retention.
Learn2Care also provides 150+ hours of leadership training to support supervisors, managers, and emerging leaders. This gives agencies a way to extend development beyond frontline training and support caregivers as they take on greater responsibilities.
State-aligned training, agency-specific learning, and compliance automation help agencies organize required and ongoing education while reducing the administrative work involved in tracking workforce training. This can become increasingly important when scaling a home care business and managing a growing workforce.
For organizations that want to tackle the caregiver shortage, Learn2Care helps close the gap between recruiting caregivers and developing the workforce by giving new employees and existing caregivers a clear path to build skills, confidence, and role readiness.
Recruitment brings caregivers into the agency, but effective onboarding and ongoing training help prepare them to succeed in their roles. By combining smarter recruitment with regular onboarding and ongoing training, home care agencies can build a more capable and sustainable caregiver workforce.
Ready to strengthen your caregiver workforce beyond recruitment?
Explore Learn2Care’s caregiver training solutions and build a better training experience from Day 1.
Reaching caregivers who aren’t actively job hunting. The pool of people searching job boards in any service area in a given week is small and contested; most qualified caregivers are currently employed.
No. Roughly half of home care applicants were aged 45 to 64 and were the least expensive to acquire; applicants aged 18 to 24 made up 3.3% of applications. Employment ads can’t target by age under Meta’s Special Ad Category, so this reflects organic response rather than selection.
Pay, shift, and location — in that order, in the first two lines. Caregivers screen on those three before reading anything about mission or culture. State a real pay range rather than ‘competitive pay.’
It should be short enough to complete on a mobile phone in under a minute. Only ask questions that actually disqualify a candidate—usually shift availability, transportation, travel radius, and any minimum requirement for experience.
Yes, and they don’t scale. Your caregivers know a finite number of caregivers. Referrals should be one channel among several, not the primary one.
Caregiver and home health aide applicants averaged $3.47. Individual agencies ranged from about $1.22 to $15, depending on service area density, screening strictness, and shift requirements.
Related Blog Posts-
Securing Stability: Proven Strategies for Caregiver Retention
Innovative Strategies for Building a Loyal Caregiver Team
Find your next read and expand your knowledge
Contact us to inquire about our state-wise training courses and take the first step towards upskilling your team with a 14-day free trial!
